It's been a good few
years since I managed two new birds in Britain in the space of a
week, with 2 or 3 a year now about my average. And who would have
expected it to happen in mid summer and in such a memorable way?
As I held the still-warm, limp and
lifeless body of the bird we had all come to see, it felt like I had
made a wonderful new friend, then watched them cross the road only to
get hit by a bus. How on earth had it come to this? How could one of
the bird world's most efficient flying machines be downed in this
cruel way like a once-great fighter jet shot clean out of the sky? In
these days of optical aids over firepower where the double barrels of
a shotgun have been replaced by double barrels packed with nitrogen
and glass prisms for your viewing pleasure, rare birds can usually
hope to live on a bit longer when they turn up here and not come to a
sudden and sticky end. But there was no denying the facts – the
culprit, the killer no less, towered over us, and we'd seen the
spectacle for ourselves – the Harris white-throated needletail, the
bird which had drawn us all to this spot, had collided with the base
of a wind turbine blade and fallen helplessly to the ground. Now it
was in my hands, a surprisingly large bird sporting features I hadn't
noticed in the field, like the sturdy dark legs (much
stronger-looking than those of our own swift) and the beautiful green
iridescence across the wing bases and tail, a tail terminating with
needle-like points to the feathers, one of the features that give the
bird its name.
I was later asked what was special
about this bird. Well, where do you start? Apart from its exceptional
rarity status (less than ten accepted sightings in the UK) and the
fact that this was the first for 22 years, it is quite simply, a
dream bird. It exudes style. And speed. Swifts are – well - swift,
but this one is the turbo model. It holds the air speed record in
level flight at a little over 100mph. It features in the top 5 'most
wanted' on the lists of many birders and holds the number one spot
for a good proportion of those. And it's only ever been 'twitchable'
on offshore Scottish islands in the nineteen-eighties.
The news came like a bombshell on the
afternoon of Tuesday 25th June. Needletail on Harris at
Tarbert, present for its second day. It turns out it was glimpsed
the day before but its identity had not been confirmed. But now there
was no denying it and a major twitch was soon underway. I left with
three friends that night, setting off at 11.40pm with a 16 hour
journey stretching before us.
A golden eagle on Skye provided a
welcome distraction from the building tension but by the time we
reached the ferry terminal on Skye our nerves were shot to pieces.
We'd heard the needletail was still present that morning, only to
find out an hour or so later that it hadn't actually been seen and
that the earlier message had been a mistake. An hour later though, we
heard it was back. Two military jets thundered overhead as we waited.
We later heard one had continued on to Harris and overflown the site
the the needletail was frequenting. It had spooked the bird which had
headed south. Not good news.
An hour and a half passed, maybe two.
It was back! Relocated two miles to the south of its last location
and we were just a few miles out from Tarbert! We docked in Tarbert
and searched eagerly for the taxi we'd booked but it wasn't there. A
stressful ten minutes ensued but at last we found the taxi and
arrived within minutes at the site a few miles down Golden Road.
There was certainly a golden prize here somewhere and it was a tense
few minutes before we made visual contact with the bird causing all
the fuss.
The needletail shot out over the
moorland, often invisible behind the uneven rocky ground but
occasionally arcing into the sky where it was easier to follow. It
effortlessly covered large tracts of moorland with few wingbeats and
suddenly for us observers it had all been worth it. The tension, the
exhaustion, the disrupted plans no longer mattered. It had been an
epic twitch and an epic day already, none of us would forget it in a
hurry.
Things were great. Our taxi-driver
turned out to be the father of the person who had first seen the bird
rather poorly and not known what it was. We sent him into Tarbert
with an order for beer and fish and chips which we later ate in the
sunshine as the bird continued to show now and then. We must have
watched the bird on and off for an hour and a half before the
collision. There were perhaps 12-15 birders present and maybe half
this number witnessed the spectacle. I was calling directions to a
birder next to me, running a commentary which went something like
'it's going right, below the wires, right of the wind turbine, going
back behind the turbine – and that's when I faltered. The bird
disappeared momentarily behind the turbine's nacelle only to fall
back and down, plummeting some thirty metres to the ground. I rushed
up the small hill and picked up the body, struggling to comprehend
what had just happened.
The bird was found to have no obvious
broken bones or external injuries and appears to have died from a
blow to the head. It was initially passed to the RSPB but is destined
eventually for the National Museum of Scotland. Naturally, there was
a great deal of press interest in the incident. The locals too were
very interested and it soon reignited the debate over wind farms and
bird collisions. Many birders were shocked and vented their anger on
forums in opposition to the 'Blades of Death' rotating in ever
increasing numbers across areas such as the Western Isles. But the
turbine involved is small, (with about a twenty metre span) and it
only serves the small village here. It is not part of a major fleet
and is most likely a sensible and efficient solution to the energy
needs of the local community.
Those in opposition to wind power might
think of this bird as a bit of a martyr. It has certainly re-ignited
the wind farm debate, and there have been many more hits on that
alarming You Tube clip of the vulture colliding with the rotating
blades of a turbine. A traumatic incident to watch, but on that
occasion the bird did survive at least. What is clear though is that
the problem of birds flying into wind turbines is not going away and
if a bird like a needletail can't avoid one, what hope is there for
other species? Large birds of prey seem to be the most vulnerable to
collisions and the Western Isles is a very important area for hen
harriers, golden eagles and sea eagles.
It was a long drive back. The entire
journey took eighteen hours, including a stop at BBC Cumbria's studio
to do a piece on TV for Newsnight (see 15 mins in here
http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b036bnmd/Newsnight_Scotland_27_06_2013/). Somewhere in southern Scotland
through the murk I spotted a large wind turbine – it was the first
I'd noticed since the collision I had witnessed. I narrowed my eyes
and glared at it as if at a new enemy but even then I was aware that
wind power has many advantages and there's no point opposing it just
because of the incident I had watched the previous day. It's a
complex debate but if wind farms are to be limited because of bird
collisions then it's the vulnerable native species we have to watch,
the number and location of collisions we have to keep tabs on. The
needletail's death was a sad event (and truly heartbreaking to
witness) but it was a quick death with presumably no suffering
involved and to lose a proportion of our breeding eagle population
due to careless positioning of large wind farms would be very much
more serious.
One thing's for sure though. Whenever I
see a wind turbine my mind will take me straight back to Harris on
that unforgettable, yet ultimately tragic, day.
The day after my return I headed to
Aldeburgh for a family holiday in a large house overloking the area
the Hornemann's redpoll frequented in December. Once I'd recovered
from the Hebs trip I managed to get out to Minsmere for a few hours'
birding in the afternoon and early evening. Little did I know another
biggie was about to break. But the local birdlife knew something was
in the air and there were some ruffled feathers about.
|
Bittern, easily identifiable due to its close resemblance to a part-eaten corn-on-the-cob |
Bridled tern – Inner Farne. Found by
photographer Rob Wilson and local ranger Will Scott. OMG. Not now
though... I used up my brownie points last week and I couldn't leave
in the middle of a family holiday! Or could I? Of course I did. I
eventually got my wife's blessing (maximum respect to the missus for
that one, she really is the best!) and headed north with Adrian
Kettle & Mark Thomas, with Adrian driving through the night to
meet the 6am charter boat.
And what can I say about the twitch?
Well it went like a dream. Calm weather, and we saw the bird on
arrival. There was a wonderful seabird spectacle all around us and
there was never a dull moment even when the bird did a bunk for an
hour or so. It was conveniently hanging round the jetty area which
was just as well as the island itself would be out of bounds until
10am by which time we'd be back on the mainland.
To have it under the belt by 6.30am was
great and we were soon homeward bound, stopping off at Coquet Island
to watch some distant roseate terns fishing in the channel in front
of the island. The bridled tern showed on and off all day, delighting
hundreds of visitors and providing significant compensation for those
unable to make the star bird of the previous week. Terns are a tough
group to connect with but this just leaves me needing Aleutian and
royal and takes away the pain of missing a Bridled in Essex just 20 or so miles from
my house back in 1991!